Photo: Myer · for identificationDesigner original, shown so you know which bottle is being compared. Bottle photo: Myer.
Carolina Herrera · 2016 · EDPFeminine
A feminine original
Desk-matched · hops to Australian shops
Top desk scorePalermo Perfumes W0924.6desk score
$0.70/ml · 50 ml
Compare 7 inspired-by alternatives
The stiletto bottle. Cocoa, tuberose, and a very loud entrance. Clones keep the juice and skip the sculpture.
What it inspired
Independent fragrances made to evoke Good Girl — not the original, and not made by Carolina Herrera. Match percentages are desk estimates.
Highest desk score first; where scores tie, houses we work with come first, then the desk's match estimate (best value: match and per-ml saving). Desk scores and match bands are this desk's own estimates — not customer reviews, not lab tests. Sold-out bottles sit last. How we rank
Some shop links are commission links: The D.I. may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Inspirations are listed top-rated first (the house's own customer reviews, otherwise our desk score); where ratings tie, houses we work with come first.
#1Palermo PerfumesAustralia — 70+ storesFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Stiletto juice without the stiletto bottle
EDP · 50 ml
$0.70/ml · 50 ml
#2JalùBexley, SydneyFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Cocoa-tuberose, skip the heel
Extrait · 50 ml
$1.40/ml · 50 ml
#4Joe SmithJoondalup / Cannington, PerthFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Stiletto juice without the sculpture, #2
EDP · 50 ml
Joe Smith doesn't publish top, heart and base notes for this bottle.
$0.70/ml · 50 ml
#5WhifBrendale, QueenslandFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Good Girl, not the Blush
Extrait · 50 ml
$1.10/ml · 50 ml
#6Cyrus ScentsSydney, NSWFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Stiletto juice, #60, not Blush
EDP · 50 ml
Cyrus Scents doesn't publish top, heart and base notes for this bottle.
$1.00/ml · 50 ml
#7Venezia PerfumesMelbourne, AustraliaFeminine
Inspired by Carolina Herrera Good Girl
W014, not Blush
EDP · 50 ml
Venezia Perfumes doesn't publish top, heart and base notes for this bottle.
$0.80/ml · 50 ml
The house
New York · est. 1980
The stiletto. Good Girl is sculpture first, cocoa-tuberose second — clones keep the juice and leave the heel.
Visit Carolina Herrera